Honestly, I think the blockchain part is the least interesting piece of this. I’m coming at it from the gym side, so devs can correct me on the technical stuff.
The real headaches with multi-gym memberships usually aren’t verifying a pass. They’re things like:
Who gets paid when someone visits three studios in a week?
Who owns the member relationship?
How do you stop one person from using a pass at ten places a day, or from lending it to a buddy?
That’s mostly business rules and trust between operators. ClassPass and Wellhub already run on regular databases, so it’s not like the tech doesn’t exist.
On your questions:
Expired/canceled memberships. An expiry date on a smart contract is easy. Cancellations, freezes, refunds and chargebacks are the messy part, because the payment itself happens off-chain on a card. Now you have to keep the billing system and the chain in sync, and when they disagree, someone’s standing at the front desk arguing with a receptionist.
Privacy. This one worries me most. On a public chain, if a wallet is tied to a pass, anyone can see where that wallet checked in and when. That’s a tracking problem. I’d keep personal data off-chain completely, and the gym should only get a yes/no on whether the pass is valid.
Is it better than existing systems? For one gym or one chain, no. A normal membership system is simpler and cheaper. It gets a bit more interesting when a group of independent studios want a shared system and none of them trusts any one of them to run it, mainly for automatic revenue splits. Even then, members have to deal with wallets and lost keys, and your average gym member isn’t going to do that to get into a spin class.
Internet going down. To me this is the strongest argument against it. If check-in depends on reading the chain live, an outage means nobody gets in. The fix is a signed pass that the door scanner can verify offline, with the expiry baked in. But at that point you’re basically describing a signed QR code, and you don’t need a blockchain for that.
So I’d say it could work for the settlement piece, but I’d be skeptical about putting access control on-chain. Has anyone here actually tried building something like this? Curious what the sync headaches looked like.